Shocking Signs of Cushioning (And How It Impacts You)

Key Takeaways:

Emotional distance may signal cushioning
Cushioning involves secretive behavior
Vague communication patterns are a red flag
Overprotectiveness of devices hides truths
Cushioning can harm long-term bonds

What is Cushioning in Relationships?

Have you ever felt like your partner is holding back emotionally, almost as if there's a safety net between you two? That, in essence, is what cushioning in relationships is all about. Cushioning is when someone keeps potential romantic interests on standby, just in case things go south with their current partner. It's not cheating, but it's definitely a breach of trust.

This behavior is surprisingly common in modern dating, fueled by the ease of staying connected to multiple people through social media and messaging apps. People might do it because they're insecure or afraid of being alone. They keep “emotional cushions” — backups — to soften the blow if their main relationship fails. However, this not only erodes the foundation of the relationship, it can also cause emotional damage on both sides.

Psychologist Dr. Jenn Mann, in her book "The Relationship Fix," mentions that "keeping people on the backburner creates a psychological distance from your primary partner," which ultimately weakens emotional bonds. We'll dive into the various signs and explore how to spot cushioning before it's too late.

Signs of Cushioning in a Relationship

Recognizing the signs of cushioning isn't always easy because it often starts as subtle behavior. Many people don't even realize it's happening to them until the emotional damage is already done. If you're wondering if your partner might be cushioning, look out for these tell-tale signs. From secretive phone behavior to a sudden lack of intimacy, cushioning can take many forms.

One major clue is when your partner seems overly interested in other people, especially if they're always texting or chatting with others in a way that makes you feel uncomfortable. Other indicators can include vague explanations about where they've been, or even a noticeable shift in how much time they spend with you. Let's break these signs down in more detail below.

Secretive Behavior and Cushioning

When someone is cushioning, secretive behavior often becomes the first noticeable sign. Does your partner seem to guard their phone like it holds national secrets? This is usually an indication that they're hiding something. Maybe they turn their phone face down on the table or walk out of the room to take calls. These actions may seem innocent at first, but over time, they can start to feel suspicious.

In the world of cushioning, personal devices play a huge role in maintaining contact with these “emotional cushions.” Your partner could be texting potential backups, and they won't want you to know about it. Dr. Mira Kirshenbaum, author of "Too Good to Leave, Too Bad to Stay," explains, “Secrecy erodes trust more than anything else in a relationship." When secrets start piling up, it's a clear sign of emotional distance.

Talking About Others Frequently

Another common sign of cushioning is when your partner constantly brings up other people, especially those they've been texting or interacting with online. Casual conversations about a coworker or an old friend might seem harmless at first, but if they're happening too often, it could be a red flag. Cushioning often involves subtly keeping others around in the background, and that can mean frequently mentioning them in conversation.

It's not just about the people they're talking to; it's how often they're bringing them up. If you notice that your partner tends to talk more about their social circle than about your relationship, this could be a sign they're emotionally hedging their bets. Pay attention to how your partner lights up when talking about someone else. It might seem small, but it can point to something much deeper at play.

Emotional Distance in Cushioning

One of the clearest signs of cushioning is when you feel a growing emotional distance from your partner. This is often a subtle, slow process, but over time, it becomes undeniable. Your partner might not seem as invested in the relationship as before, and their emotional availability becomes sparse.

It's not uncommon for someone cushioning to keep their emotions under lock and key, avoiding deep conversations and moments of vulnerability. They may pull back, not wanting to be too emotionally attached, in case things fall apart. When you notice that intimacy—both emotional and physical—is on the decline, it's worth questioning why.

This emotional disconnect isn't always obvious at first, but when the warmth and connection in your relationship start to fade, it leaves room for doubt and suspicion. The person cushioning might seem present physically but distant emotionally, which can lead to frustration and confusion on your part. Dr. John Gottman, a leading relationship expert, often states that emotional withdrawal is a key predictor of a relationship's decline.

Overprotective of Personal Devices

When it comes to cushioning, overprotectiveness of personal devices—phones, tablets, even laptops—becomes an unspoken barrier in your relationship. If your partner clutches their phone like it's their lifeline or suddenly starts locking their devices with new passwords, this could signal trouble. They might be using their devices to stay connected with those “backup” people, and they don't want you to stumble upon those conversations.

It's not about demanding to see your partner's messages, but relationships built on trust don't usually have this level of secrecy. Transparency in digital communication is often a sign of a healthy relationship, whereas cushioning thrives in secrecy and protective measures.

When personal devices become off-limits or are constantly hidden from sight, you can almost feel the barrier being created between you and your partner. It's one of the most common and modern signs of emotional distance, especially when cushioning behavior is involved.

Vague About Whereabouts

Has your partner become increasingly vague about their plans or whereabouts? One of the classic signs of cushioning is a noticeable shift in how forthcoming they are about their daily activities. They might start leaving out details about who they're meeting or where they're going. When you ask simple questions like, "Where were you?" or "Who were you with?" their answers seem annoyingly vague or dismissive.

This kind of evasion can feel like they're keeping a part of their life hidden from you, which is unsettling. Being vague about their whereabouts can be a way for someone cushioning to keep their options open without facing the immediate consequences. They avoid specifics to ensure they don't reveal too much about the other people they're keeping on standby.

For example, instead of saying, “I was out with Greg and Sarah,” you might hear, “Just out with some friends.” It's these small gaps in communication that leave room for suspicion to creep in. This lack of transparency can hurt trust over time, making you question their loyalty. When someone is cushioning, vague responses are often meant to shield their connection to the backups they're keeping in their life.

Lack of Intimacy and Cushioning

One of the most painful signs of cushioning is the gradual decline in intimacy. If you feel your partner pulling away physically, whether that's in the form of less physical affection, fewer hugs, or even a noticeable drop in sexual connection, it could be linked to emotional cushioning. When someone is emotionally invested elsewhere, even if only partially, it's hard for them to maintain the same level of intimacy with their primary partner.

Cushioning creates a divide in the emotional and physical connection. Intimacy isn't just about the physical act; it's about feeling emotionally safe and connected to your partner. When your partner is distancing themselves from you, it can feel like they're holding back or not fully “there” when you're together. This can lead to feelings of rejection or loneliness in the relationship.

Research from the Kinsey Institute highlights that a decline in intimacy often signals emotional or psychological withdrawal. When your partner seems less interested in closeness, whether emotionally or physically, cushioning could be the underlying reason. This lack of intimacy is one of the more direct ways cushioning shows up, leaving you to feel disconnected and undervalued in the relationship.

Defensiveness as a Sign of Cushioning

If you notice your partner becoming increasingly defensive when questioned about their behavior, this could be a strong sign of cushioning. Defensiveness is often a way to deflect attention and avoid accountability. When someone feels caught or even just suspected of something, they may react with hostility or irritation to shut down the conversation.

For example, if you ask why they've been spending so much time texting someone else, and their immediate response is something like, “Why are you always accusing me of things?” instead of addressing the concern, that defensiveness is a major red flag. It's a protective mechanism to avoid dealing with the discomfort of their actions being exposed.

According to relationship therapist Esther Perel, “Defensiveness often masks guilt, shame, or fear of confrontation.” If your partner seems overly sensitive to even minor questions about their behavior, it's worth paying attention. Defensiveness in the context of cushioning usually means there's more going on beneath the surface than they're willing to admit.

Changes in Communication Patterns

Communication is the foundation of any healthy relationship, so when that pattern shifts, it's usually a sign that something is off. If your partner has started communicating with you less, or the way they communicate has changed—shorter texts, delayed responses, or a general lack of engagement—it could be an indication that their focus has shifted elsewhere. In the context of cushioning, these changes often happen because the person is dividing their attention between you and others.

One major shift to watch out for is if your partner used to share details about their day or seemed eager to connect but now offers only minimal interaction. If conversations feel forced or distant, cushioning could be playing a role. The person may feel they need to emotionally distance themselves to manage their side relationships, causing a noticeable change in the tone and frequency of communication.

Another subtle but significant sign is if they seem distracted when you're talking, as if their mind is elsewhere. These changes might not happen overnight, but gradually, they build up to create an emotional barrier between you. Clear and open communication is essential, and when cushioning is involved, that crucial element often starts to fade away.

Flirtatious Behavior in Cushioning

Flirting outside of your relationship can be another sign of cushioning, especially if it's becoming a frequent behavior. While harmless flirting might seem innocent to some, in the context of cushioning, it's often a way for someone to keep their options open. They may not be actively seeking out another relationship, but by engaging in flirtatious conversations with others, they maintain emotional backups.

If your partner is constantly engaging with others in a way that feels inappropriate—whether it's through texting, social media, or in person—it could be more than just friendly banter. They might be testing the waters with potential emotional cushions, feeling out who might be available as a backup if things go south in your relationship.

Psychologist Dr. Linda Young explains in her article for Psychology Today that “consistent flirtation can be a way to subtly check out of your current relationship without fully committing to leaving.” When flirtatious behavior becomes a pattern, it can weaken the trust and intimacy in your relationship, further signaling the presence of cushioning.

Reasons for Cushioning

Why do people cushion in relationships? The reasons can vary, but often it comes down to insecurity, fear of being alone, or dissatisfaction with the current relationship. For some, cushioning is a way to avoid putting all their emotional eggs in one basket. They keep other options around, just in case the relationship they're in doesn't work out. It's a safety net.

Others may cushion out of a fear of commitment. By maintaining emotional distance and keeping others in the picture, they can avoid the full vulnerability of being invested in just one person. This can be especially common in people who have experienced past heartbreaks or trauma, where cushioning becomes a way to protect themselves from potential future pain.

Still, others might not even realize they're cushioning. Social media has made it easy to maintain connections with people from the past or interact with new people in subtle ways that don't seem like a big deal. But when those connections start to serve as emotional buffers, it can cause real damage to the primary relationship.

Ultimately, cushioning is a symptom of deeper emotional issues—whether it's fear, insecurity, or dissatisfaction. And while it may offer temporary comfort to the person doing the cushioning, it creates lasting harm in the relationship.

The Emotional Impact of Cushioning

The emotional toll cushioning takes on a relationship is often immense, and it affects both partners. If you're on the receiving end, you might feel confused, distant, or like something is "off" but can't quite put your finger on it. There's a growing sense that your partner is no longer fully present, and this emotional distance can create feelings of insecurity, mistrust, and loneliness.

Being cushioned can leave you questioning your worth in the relationship. Are you not enough? Is your partner already halfway out the door? These questions can spark anxiety, making it difficult to maintain emotional stability. In some cases, the emotional pain of cushioning is even more damaging than infidelity because it involves a constant undercurrent of doubt and fear rather than a single event.

For the person doing the cushioning, it's not always smooth sailing either. They might feel guilt or a growing sense of dissatisfaction with their behavior. Cushioning can lead to an emotional tug-of-war, where the person feels caught between their primary partner and the safety nets they've created. Over time, this emotional dissonance can build, leaving both partners feeling disconnected and unfulfilled.

Cushioning in the Dating World

Cushioning has become a common phenomenon in today's dating landscape, largely thanks to social media and dating apps. With the ability to connect with multiple people at once, some daters keep potential partners on the back burner while they explore other options. The digital age has made it easier than ever to maintain these side connections without feeling the need to fully commit.

In the world of casual dating, cushioning can sometimes be seen as normal behavior. People justify it by saying they're not technically committed to anyone, so what's the harm in keeping options open? But even in these early stages of dating, cushioning can prevent real emotional connections from forming. It keeps relationships in a limbo state, where no one fully invests in anyone else.

Dating coach Matthew Hussey notes, “Cushioning might seem like a way to avoid heartbreak, but it actually stops us from building the kind of connection that leads to lasting love.” While it's understandable to want to protect yourself in the uncertainty of dating, cushioning creates a cycle where no relationship can truly thrive. The temporary comfort cushioning provides only delays the emotional work needed to build a healthy, committed partnership.

What Does it Mean to Cushion Someone?

Cushioning someone means keeping them emotionally on standby while you're in a relationship with someone else. It's like having a backup plan—an emotional buffer to soften the blow if your current relationship doesn't work out. The person doing the cushioning may engage in subtle flirting, texting, or maintaining connections with potential romantic interests, just enough to keep the door open without committing fully to anyone else.

It's important to note that cushioning isn't the same as cheating. There's usually no physical affair happening. Instead, it's about emotional hedging. The person cushioning creates a sense of security for themselves by knowing there are others they could potentially fall back on if things go south in their main relationship. It might seem harmless, but it leads to a lack of emotional honesty and undermines trust in the relationship.

While the person cushioning may see it as a way to protect themselves from future heartbreak, the act of cushioning can cause deep emotional damage to their partner, who may sense the emotional distance but can't pinpoint why. Cushioning is a form of emotional dishonesty that keeps relationships in a state of limbo.

How to Recognize If You Are Being Cushioned

Wondering if you're being cushioned? The signs aren't always obvious, but there are several key behaviors to watch for. One major red flag is if your partner is secretive or evasive about their interactions with others. Are they overly protective of their phone? Do they deflect or get defensive when you ask about their relationships with others? These are common signs that they may be cushioning.

Another clue is if your partner frequently talks about other people, especially in a flirtatious or admiring way. They may not be doing anything explicitly wrong, but the fact that they are keeping others in the conversation—literally and figuratively—can signal that they are hedging their bets. You might feel like they're never fully “in” the relationship with you because their attention is divided.

Emotional distance is another key indicator. If your partner seems less emotionally available or is withdrawing from intimacy, it could be because they're investing part of their emotional energy elsewhere. This shift can be subtle at first but becomes more noticeable as time goes on. If you feel like you're being kept at arm's length, cushioning could be the reason.

Ultimately, trust your gut. If you feel something isn't right, it's worth having an open and honest conversation with your partner. Cushioning thrives in secrecy, and addressing it head-on is the first step in getting clarity on where your relationship stands.

What is an Emotional Cushion?

An emotional cushion refers to someone who is kept in reserve—someone who offers emotional support or validation but isn't fully integrated into the relationship. This person becomes a backup option, providing comfort and reassurance without any direct commitment. The person cushioning might casually text or keep in touch with the emotional cushion, using them to maintain a sense of security.

This relationship dynamic is one-sided. The emotional cushion may not even realize they're being used in this way, believing the connection is genuine. On the surface, the relationship seems friendly or flirtatious, but beneath it lies an ulterior motive: they are there to make the person cushioning feel safer about their current relationship, a fallback if things go wrong.

Emotional cushions often fulfill needs that the primary partner may not be addressing, such as validation or attention. However, this form of emotional insurance prevents both parties from engaging in a fully committed, emotionally honest relationship. Over time, this dynamic fosters disconnection rather than growth.

How Cushioning Affects Long-Term Relationships

Cushioning can cause significant damage to long-term relationships. The emotional distance created by maintaining backups undermines trust and intimacy, two crucial elements of a healthy, lasting relationship. When one partner cushions, they're essentially half-investing in their relationship, which limits the emotional depth that can be reached with their primary partner.

Over time, cushioning erodes the foundation of the relationship. The primary partner often senses that something is wrong, even if they can't pinpoint it. This uncertainty can lead to feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and resentment. For the person doing the cushioning, their own emotional energy is split between the current relationship and the emotional cushions, preventing them from fully committing.

Long-term, cushioning can create a cycle of emotional withdrawal. Both partners begin to drift further apart, making it difficult to rebuild trust. According to Dr. Sue Johnson, a leading psychologist in relationship therapy, “emotional connection is the key to a thriving relationship.” Without it, the relationship becomes stagnant, leaving both parties feeling unfulfilled. Cushioning might offer temporary security, but in the long run, it destroys the emotional connection needed for a meaningful and lasting relationship.

Reflecting on Cushioning in Relationships

Cushioning may seem like a subtle or even harmless behavior, but its impact on relationships is far from trivial. Whether intentional or not, cushioning creates emotional distance, erodes trust, and undermines the intimacy that every strong relationship requires. It's a way to hedge your bets, but it comes at the cost of authenticity and emotional honesty.

If you're experiencing cushioning in your relationship, it's important to confront the issue head-on. This means having open conversations about the behaviors you're noticing, expressing your concerns, and addressing the emotional gaps. Cushioning can only thrive in secrecy and avoidance, so shining a light on the issue is the first step toward healing.

On the flip side, if you recognize yourself as the person cushioning, it's time to reflect on why you feel the need to keep emotional backups. Is it fear of commitment? A lack of trust in your partner? By understanding the root causes, you can start addressing the real issues in your relationship rather than using cushioning as an emotional crutch.

Ultimately, relationships require vulnerability and commitment to thrive. Cushioning only serves as a barrier to true connection. It may offer temporary emotional security, but it will prevent you from building the deep, fulfilling relationship you deserve.

Sign In