10 Urgent Questions to Ask Your Unfaithful Spouse (Now)

Key Takeaways:

Confront the core of infidelity
Understand emotional and psychological impacts
Questions that reveal deeper truths
Handling lies and half-truths
Healing and rebuilding trust

What led you to allow yourself to cheat?

It's a tough question, but it's one that digs deep. Asking your spouse why they gave themselves permission to step outside the relationship goes beyond surface-level curiosity. It gets to the heart of their moral and emotional reasoning. Was it a moment of weakness, or did they justify it to themselves over time?

Psychologist Esther Perel, in her book "The State of Affairs", points out that infidelity isn't always about a failing marriage, but rather about an individual searching for themselves. “Affairs are way less about sex and much more about desire: desire for attention, desire to feel special, desire to feel alive.” If we ask this question, it can open a window into their motivations and self-deception.

Here's the reality: answering this question might sting, but it also shines a light on their thought process—allowing us to understand the "why" behind their actions.

Did you feel guilty during or after the affair?

Guilt is an indicator of empathy. If your spouse felt guilty, that means they at least had some awareness of the pain their actions would cause you. However, if they didn't feel guilty, it could suggest deeper emotional distance or even detachment from the relationship.

We often believe that guilt automatically follows infidelity, but that's not always the case. Some may justify their actions so thoroughly in their mind that guilt doesn't surface until much later—or not at all. According to research from Dr. Paul Amato, a professor of sociology, those who avoid guilt often use mechanisms like compartmentalization, where they separate the affair from their primary relationship to minimize emotional conflict.

This question forces your spouse to reflect on whether their actions weighed on them emotionally, and whether they felt that burden while the affair was happening, or only after being caught. Their response can reveal their emotional investment in your relationship, or lack thereof.

Is this the first affair, or have there been others?

When asking whether this is the first affair, you are really looking for a pattern. Affairs don't always come out of nowhere, and discovering that this isn't the first time can completely shift how you view the relationship. There's a significant difference between a one-time betrayal and a repeated pattern of infidelity.

If your spouse admits to multiple affairs, it can point to a deeper issue within them, or even a disregard for the emotional impact these actions have had on you. As relationship expert Dr. Shirley Glass notes in her book "Not Just Friends", “repeated affairs aren't about the failing relationship; they're about unresolved personal issues.” This kind of revelation can be deeply painful, but also crucial in deciding the future of your marriage.

Whether it's the first time or not, the answer to this question will inform how you move forward—whether it's working to repair things or choosing a different path.

What did you tell them about our relationship?

This question is heavy, and it's hard not to feel like you're peeling back layers of hurt as you ask it. When your spouse tells someone else about your relationship, they may either sugarcoat or criticize it to justify their actions. Knowing what they said can expose how they truly viewed your marriage at the time.

Some cheaters paint a picture of their marriage as loveless or broken to their affair partner, which can sting even more because it's often an exaggeration or distortion. Did they make it sound like you were distant or neglectful? Did they blame you for their infidelity? These answers are painful, but they offer insight into how your spouse has been thinking and feeling about your relationship.

How they presented your relationship to the affair partner can reveal a lot about their mindset and whether they've been honest with themselves—or with you—about where things went wrong.

Did you ever consider leaving me for them?

This question hits hard, doesn't it? You're essentially asking if the affair ever became serious enough for your spouse to contemplate a life without you. While some people see their affair as purely physical or emotional escapism, others cross into dangerous territory where they imagine leaving their partner altogether.

The answer here can give you a sense of the weight the affair carried in their mind. If they did consider leaving, it forces you both to confront just how far things went and whether their heart had truly wandered. If they didn't, it might suggest that, despite the betrayal, they never actually intended to end the marriage.

Whatever the answer, it's going to sting. But this conversation helps bring clarity to the depth of the emotional investment they made in the affair and what it meant to them in comparison to your relationship.

How did the affair change the way you see us?

Affairs don't just damage trust—they shift perspectives. Whether they admit it or not, an affair can alter how your spouse views both you and your marriage. Asking this question opens the door to understanding how their perception of your relationship has evolved post-affair.

Maybe the affair made them realize the things they've taken for granted in your relationship. Or perhaps it left them more confused about what they want. In some cases, the affair creates a jarring contrast between what they thought they wanted and what they now see they had with you. Psychologist Janis Abrahms Spring, in her book "After the Affair", explains that many people come out of an affair feeling disillusioned with both the affair and their marriage, but also with themselves. This question allows your spouse to verbalize those thoughts, however messy or contradictory they may be.

The answer to this could give you valuable insight into their mindset and whether they're truly willing to rebuild, or if they see the relationship through a changed—and possibly damaged—lens.

Did your affair partner provide something you felt was missing?

Affairs often fill a gap, whether it's emotional, physical, or psychological. Asking this question forces your spouse to reflect on what they were searching for outside the marriage. Maybe it was a sense of adventure, emotional connection, or validation that they weren't getting from you—or at least that's how they perceived it.

This doesn't mean you're at fault. Often, people who cheat are filling an internal void, not necessarily one created by the relationship. Dr. Mira Kirshenbaum, author of "When Good People Have Affairs", explains that many people don't even realize what they're missing until they have an affair. “The affair is a symptom, not the cause,” she writes, pointing to the personal crises people go through that lead them to seek out something—or someone—else.

Understanding what your spouse was chasing in their affair doesn't excuse their behavior, but it can offer insight into the deeper layers of dissatisfaction they've been carrying. It also helps you assess whether these gaps can be addressed within your relationship.

Did you talk about a future with this person?

This question asks your spouse to face the full reality of their actions. If they were fantasizing or even actively discussing a future with the person they cheated with, it suggests a deeper emotional involvement than a one-time mistake. This could indicate that, for them, the affair wasn't just a fleeting indulgence but something they were invested in, perhaps more than they were willing to admit.

Some people will never talk about the future with their affair partner, seeing it as an escape that has no place in the real world. Others may dive into emotional intimacy, weaving fantasies about what life would look like with this new person. According to Dr. Helen Fisher, a biological anthropologist, when people talk about a future with someone, their brain chemistry mimics that of falling in love. It's a powerful bond, even if the relationship isn't built to last.

How your spouse answers this question can help you determine just how far they were willing to go, and whether the affair ever threatened your long-term relationship.

Do you want to stay in our marriage?

This is the ultimate question. After everything that's happened, does your spouse genuinely want to remain in the marriage? Asking this forces them to be brutally honest, both with you and themselves. While you might already suspect the answer, hearing them say it out loud makes all the difference. It shifts the conversation from analyzing the past to deciding the future.

Even if your spouse claims they want to stay, the next step is evaluating whether that desire is rooted in genuine commitment or fear of change. Many people stay in a marriage out of comfort or guilt, but those reasons won't sustain a relationship in the long run. In her book "Too Good to Leave, Too Bad to Stay", therapist Mira Kirshenbaum explains that understanding the reasons behind staying is critical. “Choosing to stay must come from a place of wanting to work on the relationship, not just avoiding the discomfort of leaving,” she advises.

Whether they say yes or no, this question will define the path you take together or apart.

Did you ever think of me while with them?

This is a heartbreaking question to ask, but it needs to be asked. Knowing whether your spouse thought about you while they were with the other person reveals how deeply the betrayal ran. Did they compartmentalize the affair to avoid confronting the reality of hurting you? Or were you always present in their mind, even if in a distant way?

Some people who cheat will admit they blocked their partner from their thoughts, while others carry guilt and regret throughout the affair. According to Dr. Frank Pittman, author of "Private Lies", “Guilt is often the one thread that keeps a cheater connected to their original partner, even if they're not willing to admit it.” If your spouse thought of you during the affair, it might signal that part of them knew they were causing harm, even if they didn't stop.

The answer to this question won't change what happened, but it will provide insight into their emotional and mental state during the affair and how it truly impacted them on a deeper level.

How long did the affair last?

The length of the affair can be just as painful to hear as the betrayal itself. Knowing whether it was a short-lived fling or a long-term deception will change the way you view what happened. A longer affair indicates a deeper investment, both emotionally and physically. It often involves lying for weeks, months, or even years—each day a fresh betrayal.

Understanding the timeline also gives you context for other moments in your relationship. Were there signs you missed? Did they behave differently during that time? You may find that events you once brushed off suddenly take on new meaning. It's a painful discovery, but it's part of understanding the full scope of the situation. Dr. Janis Abrahms Spring emphasizes in "After the Affair" that the duration of an affair can signal its impact: “The longer the affair lasts, the more likely it is that your partner formed a real emotional connection, making the process of recovery more complex.”

Asking how long the affair lasted isn't just about gathering details—it's about assessing how much of your life together has been overshadowed by this deception.

What to do if your spouse refuses to answer?

Sometimes, asking the hard questions doesn't yield the answers you need. If your spouse shuts down or refuses to answer, it puts you in an even tougher spot. Their refusal can mean a lot of things—maybe they're overwhelmed by guilt, ashamed of their actions, or simply unwilling to confront the truth. But at the end of the day, their refusal to engage doesn't absolve them from responsibility.

So, what do you do? Start by giving them space to process, but don't let them avoid accountability forever. If they refuse to answer key questions, you'll have to decide whether you're comfortable staying in the dark about crucial parts of their infidelity. In many cases, it might be time to bring in a professional, like a couples therapist, to mediate the conversation. As psychotherapist Esther Perel suggests, “Silence doesn't protect the relationship, it suffocates it. The healing process begins when both partners are willing to talk.”

If your spouse continues to refuse, you may need to weigh how much you're willing to fight for answers versus moving forward without them. This refusal could indicate deeper issues with honesty and transparency that need addressing before any healing can happen.

How to handle dishonesty from your spouse?

Dealing with dishonesty from someone you trusted deeply is like navigating a minefield. When your spouse continues to lie even after being caught, it's not just frustrating—it's damaging to the core of your relationship. But you can't ignore the dishonesty and hope it will go away. Addressing it head-on is critical to either rebuilding the relationship or understanding if it's time to walk away.

If your spouse refuses to be truthful, you need to set clear boundaries. Let them know that honesty is non-negotiable moving forward. This isn't just about the affair itself—it's about the trust that must be rebuilt for your relationship to survive. Relationship therapist Harriet Lerner advises in "The Dance of Deception", “A relationship based on lies will not heal. The truth, as painful as it may be, is the foundation of any chance at reconciliation.”

Be prepared to walk away if dishonesty continues. A relationship can't thrive without transparency, and if your spouse can't provide that, it may be time to consider whether this is a battle worth fighting.

Signs your spouse might be lying about cheating

It's often hard to distinguish between denial and deception, especially when emotions are running high. But there are certain signs to look for when you suspect your spouse is still lying about the affair. One major red flag is inconsistency. If their story keeps changing or they can't keep track of what they've told you, it's a sign that they're trying to cover up the truth.

Another indicator is defensiveness. If your spouse becomes overly defensive or even hostile when you ask about the affair, they might still be hiding something. As Dr. Pamela Meyer, author of "Liespotting", explains, “Liars often resort to aggression when they feel trapped by the truth.”

Watch for nonverbal cues as well. Things like avoiding eye contact, fidgeting, or giving overly detailed explanations can suggest that they're not being completely honest. Trust your instincts—if something feels off, it probably is. These subtle signs might point to deeper dishonesty that needs to be addressed if you're going to move forward in any meaningful way.

What to check to confirm suspicions

When you suspect your spouse of cheating, relying on vague feelings of unease won't give you the clarity you need. There are specific things you can check to either confirm or dismiss your suspicions. Start by looking at their phone or social media activity—changes in behavior like suddenly guarding their phone or deleting messages are red flags. You might also notice that they're spending more time “working late” or going on unexplained trips.

Check for sudden changes in appearance or lifestyle. Did they start working out more, buying new clothes, or taking more care in their grooming? While these things on their own don't prove anything, combined with other signs, they can be telling. As cheating expert Robert Weiss writes in his book "Out of the Doghouse", “Affairs usually bring about subtle changes in a person's routine that, if noticed, can reveal what's been happening behind the scenes.”

Sometimes, it's helpful to trust your gut. If their behavior has drastically changed and explanations don't add up, it's worth digging deeper. But remember, accusations without evidence can damage the relationship further—so tread carefully.

Steps to discover the truth

Discovering the truth about an affair isn't always straightforward. It can take time, persistence, and sometimes, professional help. Start by having an open and honest conversation. Tell your spouse what you've noticed and how it makes you feel. But if they continue to deny or avoid the truth, you may need to take more direct action.

One approach is to look at digital evidence. Check phone bills, emails, or social media activity. While it can feel invasive, sometimes these are the only ways to uncover the truth. Be mindful that this step can backfire if not handled carefully—if your spouse feels like you're invading their privacy, it could make communication even harder.

If you're still not getting answers, consider bringing in a professional. A therapist or marriage counselor can help guide difficult conversations, and if needed, a private investigator can provide concrete evidence. According to relationship expert Shirley Glass in her book "Not Just Friends", “The truth always comes out, but how it's discovered can either heal or deepen the hurt.” Knowing when to escalate the search for truth is critical in deciding how to move forward.

How to decide the future of your marriage

Deciding whether to stay or leave after infidelity is one of the hardest choices you'll ever face. The answer isn't always clear, and there's no one-size-fits-all solution. The decision involves assessing both your emotional needs and your spouse's willingness to rebuild trust. One of the first questions to ask yourself is: Can I forgive them? Forgiveness doesn't mean forgetting what happened, but it's essential if you want to move forward together.

You'll also need to evaluate your spouse's actions post-affair. Are they genuinely remorseful? Are they willing to work on the relationship, or are they only offering empty promises? Relationship expert Dr. John Gottman emphasizes the importance of both partners taking responsibility: “Without accountability and commitment, reconciliation is nearly impossible.”

Ultimately, the decision comes down to whether you believe the relationship can heal and whether you both are ready to put in the work. It may take time to get to this answer, and that's okay. What matters is that the decision is based on honest reflection, not rushed emotions.

When to seek help after discovering infidelity

Knowing when to seek help after discovering an affair can be tricky. Some people rush to counseling right away, while others hesitate, hoping they can fix things on their own. There's no wrong timeline, but the sooner you involve a professional, the sooner you can start working through the pain in a constructive way.

If you find yourself stuck in a cycle of blame and defensiveness with no real progress, it's time to seek outside help. A trained therapist or counselor can offer a neutral space for both of you to express your feelings and start rebuilding trust. Dr. Sue Johnson, the creator of Emotionally Focused Therapy, says, “Couples therapy can help you both understand the underlying emotions driving your behavior and how to reestablish connection.”

Therapy isn't a sign of failure—it's a tool to help you navigate a complex situation. If you want to heal, asking for help is often the first step toward a clearer, healthier path forward.

Tips for rebuilding trust post-affair

Rebuilding trust after an affair is like trying to reconstruct a house that's been destroyed by fire. The foundation may still be there, but it's going to take time, patience, and commitment to restore it to what it once was—if not something even stronger. Trust doesn't come back overnight, and both partners must be willing to put in the effort to make it work.

The first step is complete transparency. Your spouse needs to be an open book—no more secrets, no more hidden conversations. This might mean sharing phone passwords, explaining where they're going, or keeping an open dialogue about their feelings and intentions. While this level of openness might feel invasive at first, it's a necessary step to rebuild that broken bond.

Second, be patient with the healing process. Trust isn't something that can be forced. It will take time for you to feel secure again, and that's normal. Relationship expert Brené Brown talks about the importance of “vulnerability” in rebuilding trust. In her book "Daring Greatly", she says, “Trust is built in small moments, not grand gestures. It's a slow, ongoing process.” Let yourself heal at your own pace, and allow your partner to prove they're trustworthy again through consistent actions.

Finally, focus on forgiveness. While forgiveness doesn't mean forgetting, it does mean letting go of the constant anger and resentment that can keep you both stuck in the past. Forgiving your spouse is an essential part of moving forward, both for your own peace of mind and the health of the relationship. If forgiveness feels impossible on your own, seeking help from a counselor or therapist can provide the guidance needed to work through the lingering pain.

Sign In